17 Comments
User's avatar
Jon's avatar

Really enjoyed this. For me, your take at the end using Cynthia rather than Vlad' really added flavour.

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

Thanks! I wasn't overly taken with Vlad, he was a bit flat for me!

Expand full comment
Larisa Rimerman's avatar

It is beautiful. Endlessness of water and our reading. Openness of water and the books. Mystery of water and a book. Wisdom of water and a book. Enjoyment of water and a book. Danger of water and a book…

Expand full comment
Eleanor Jones's avatar

I love this new way of reflecting on what has affected you in the past month. This sounds like such an unusual book, I love nuanced looks at sex and power, considering unlikeable and sometimes uncomfortable storylines. Thank you for sharing :)

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

Thank you! I really enjoyed playing around with the format so I'm glad u liked it ☺️

Expand full comment
Lucy Hearne Keane's avatar

This is a book I am unacquainted with, and your review is really helpful. A very funny book I read some years ago about academia with a female narrator is Jane Smiley's Moo. I read it when I was working as an academic and I could resonate with so much of the craziness of the academic world. It's tongue in cheek humour with an underlying scrutiny of that particular world.

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

Thanks, Lucy! Ah, I haven’t heard of Moo, I will put it on my list to check out- thanks :)

Expand full comment
Joanna Clare Dobson's avatar

I enjoyed it a lot, Kate! Definitely something to repeat as long it’s something you enjoy writing.

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

Thank, Joanna! I wasn’t sure, but the shorter, reflective essay was fun to write!

Expand full comment
Joanna Clare Dobson's avatar

I enjoyed it a lot, Kate! Definitely something to repeat as long it’s something you enjoy writing.

Expand full comment
Michelle's avatar

The monthly wrap-up post is a challenge. I am still working on how I do mine and have yet to feel inspired without stealing someone else's interesting idea!

Other books that have an academic-as-lead:

White on White by Ayşegül Savaş. The protagonist is writing her phd in art history. She is obsessed with her landlady who is an artist.

Landscapes by Christine Lai. I didn't love the book but I did enjoy elements of it. I did read it a while ago but there are two POVs and the female is a curator in a near future UK that is impacted by climate change. She is archiving the art/artefacts that are part of the collection of her husband's estate. There are some trigger warnings.

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

It is, isn’t it?! I find myself both loving and feeling intimidated by other people’s roundups! Thank you for the recommendations; White on White sounds particularly interesting to me.

Expand full comment
Matthew's avatar

My comments...

A superb review, not only of the novel, but also your reaction to it.

I wouldn't call it short.

You are an integral member of substack's reader/reviewer culture. A woman of letters!

On the fiction side of things I'm reading Madam Bovary. Non fiction at the moment is a philosophy tome "The World and Us" by R. M. Unger (2024).

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

Thanks so much, Matthew! I read Madam Bovary as an English Lit undergrad. It has some interesting themes.

Expand full comment
haley larsen, phd's avatar

Oh, I really love this new format, Kate! This is a fun way to learn about new books while also learning about what you resonate with -- a lot of these themes feel familiar to the "modernist" books you often write about here, but then there's that neat contemporary bend that makes it feel different and fresh, too. Thank you!! Adding it to my TBR...

Expand full comment
Kate Jones's avatar

Excellent! Thank you, Haley. I wasn’t sure, but it was fun to write! Definitely love to hear your take on the book when you’ve read it.

Expand full comment
Baird Brightman's avatar

Sex! Power! Marketing! Hype!

'Cause, you know, who would want to read a novel that's just about people and their complicated lives?

Expand full comment